iDream Education

CSR & NGO leaders: Are you becoming the system you wanted to change?

We ask governments to put learning before installations. Are we doing the same when we procure?


Published: August 2026

Image from the newsletter "CSR & NGO leaders: Are you becoming the system you wanted to change?"

Hi,

As we celebrate Independence Day, warm wishes to you and your team.

Independence Day is a reminder of both – the freedom we have inherited and the responsibility we carry to build the country we want to see. In the development sector, that responsibility often comes down to the choices we make – what we prioritise, how we use resources, and whether the decisions we take ultimately create meaningful change for the people we serve.

That thought brings me to a question I have been thinking about for some time: when a programme team and a procurement team disagree on a learning partner, who ultimately gets to decide?

It sounds like a point for an organisation's internal discussion, but it isn't. The answer determines what a teacher gets to use, what a child gets to experience, and ultimately, whether an intervention delivers the learning outcomes it was designed for.

A programme team can spend months understanding a problem inside a government school. They speak to teachers, observe classrooms, and think carefully about what will actually work with 40 children in a room, limited infrastructure, and, sometimes, patchy internet. All of that understanding goes into designing an intervention that is meant to work in that particular context.

Once this intervention is ready to be delivered, Procurement is required to bring in an external partner to implement it. The programme team may define what the partner needs to be able to do, but the procurement team is then responsible for running the process through which that partner is selected.

And this is where things can start to shift. The question deviates from “Which partner is most likely to help us achieve the outcome we want?” to “Which vendor can deliver this at the lowest price?”

That shift may sound small. It isn't.

The word partner implies a shared responsibility for the outcome. Vendor implies that we are primarily buying something. And when learning solutions are treated primarily as a procurement exercise, things such as content quality, teacher usability, data security, implementation support, and contextual fit can slowly become compliance questions rather than factors that meaningfully influence the decision.

This is not an argument against procurement; it has an important job to do. NGOs and CSR teams have a responsibility to use resources carefully, maintain transparency, and get value for money. But value for money cannot simply mean the lowest price. If one solution is cheaper to install but requires significantly more support to sustain, is it really the lower-cost option? And if the cheaper solution compromises learning, should we still call it better value? For me, these are not procurement questions alone. They are questions about the impact we are ultimately responsible for creating.

Are We Holding Ourselves to the Same Standard?

We have spent years asking governments to look beyond installations, device distributions, and the number of schools reached. We have argued, rightly, that the real measure is what happens after an intervention reaches the classroom – whether a teacher actually uses it, whether a child engages with it, and whether learning improves. And I worry that we may be slowly recreating some of the same mistakes we have spent years questioning elsewhere. When cost, reach, or the number of schools covered becomes easier to measure than actual learning, it is very easy for those numbers to start becoming proxies for impact. And once that happens, we risk optimising for what is easiest to report rather than what actually makes a difference in the classroom.

I’ve shared this perspective on LinkedIn as well, and the conversation is already bringing in some interesting views from others in the sector. Read what others are saying and share your own experience here.

So, perhaps, the question isn't “Procurement or Programme?”
It is: “How do we make sure both teams are accountable for the same thing – the outcome in the classroom?”

Programme teams bring the context. Procurement teams bring discipline, transparency, and financial rigour. Both are necessary. When there is a genuine trade-off between cost and learning, the impact lens has to have a seat at the table.

So I’ll leave you with this: when cost and impact point in different directions, who gets the final say in your organisation?

Thanks and regards,

Rohit Prakash
CEO & Co-Founder

iDream Education

Join our Newsletter

New perspectives, practical lessons and field stories from classrooms and programmes across India — delivered to your inbox.

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy